Digital Analogue
Comments: Dancing with the Stars, pt 6

"Pressure from above"? Ya think? I'm thinking the word you're really looking for is "rigged"! While it's true that the marks have been inflated throughout the series (did anyone get lower than a five, ever?), I was pretty happy with John's first 27.

When they got the second 27, though, I knew that I was going to be annoyed. You see, that gave them a 54 total, and the only way Kelly was going to win (the judges) was if she could add something to her 25 to make it better than 54... which means she had to get a perfect 30. It was obvious it was coming. It was exactly the kind of cheap "dramatic" shit that I'd expect.

I held out hope until the last moment that they were going to declare it a tie, but no. So the segment of the viewing public smart enough to know that the game was rigged (note: not the core demographic, apparently) winds up disgruntled. And John? He looked like he was thoroughly restraining himself from yelling out "the fix is in!" I wonder if he was told ahead of time that he would not be winning. I'm pretty sure Kelly was not told ahead of time that she would be. Would the judges still have given her a perfect 30 if she'd actually fallen, as she almost did twice? Hmph. All in all, it leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

Of course, if they do another season (as I'm sure they will), I'll probably watch it anyway. *sigh* Maybe I am part of their core demographic after all.

Posted by Greg at 12:43pm on 7 Jul 2005
I can't speak for the judges. All I can say is that I was incredibly disappointed by the scores they gave last night. As for the reason John didn't win . . . let's face it. Many of the people he really appeals to, the people who know what to look for in a good routine, the ones who are going to appreciate the amazing job done by a handsome older man, are also less likely to vote. I know that Greg, for one, never bothered. Kelly improved amazingly over the course of the show. And I was impressed by that. But I was more impressed by the fact that John managed to present an overall show, a performance, that beat the others hands-down. (I'm just ignoring his samba. That's a really hard one.) And even when I was impressed the Kelly's improvement . . . I still couldn't get over the clumsiness that still existed.
Posted by Carrie at 5:26pm on 7 Jul 2005
Post a comment









Write this number out in numeral form: nine hundred and twenty one
 [?]

Remember personal info?